31st Kio Match Game 4

[Black "Moriuchi Toshiyuki, Challenger"]
[White "Habu Yoshiharu, Kio"]
[Event "31st Kio-sen, Game 4"]
[Date "March 11th 2006"]
1.P7g-7f     00:00:00  00:00:00
2.P3c-3d     00:00:00  00:01:00
3.P2g-2f     00:00:00  00:01:00
4.G4a-3b     00:00:00  00:02:00
5.G6i-7h     00:15:00  00:02:00
6.P8c-8d     00:15:00  00:08:00
7.P2f-2e     00:15:00  00:08:00
8.B2bx8h+    00:15:00  00:09:00
9.S7ix8h     00:15:00  00:09:00
10.S3a-2b    00:15:00  00:09:00
11.S3i-3h    00:18:00  00:09:00
12.S2b-3c    00:18:00  00:10:00
13.P4g-4f    00:18:00  00:10:00
14.S7a-7b    00:18:00  00:12:00
15.S3h-4g    00:18:00  00:12:00
16.P6c-6d    00:18:00  00:12:00
17.S8h-7g    00:23:00  00:12:00
18.S7b-6c    00:23:00  00:14:00
19.K5i-6h    00:23:00  00:14:00
20.K5a-4b    00:23:00  00:20:00
21.G4i-5h    00:23:00  00:20:00
22.G6a-5b    00:23:00  00:23:00
23.K6h-7i    00:28:00  00:23:00
24.P7c-7d    00:28:00  00:26:00
25.P6g-6f    00:30:00  00:26:00
26.S6c-5d    00:30:00  00:33:00
27.P3g-3f    00:31:00  00:33:00
28.P1c-1d    00:31:00  00:38:00
29.P1g-1f    00:31:00  00:38:00
30.K4b-3a    00:31:00  00:48:00
31.N2i-3g    00:33:00  00:48:00
32.P9c-9d    00:33:00  01:00:00
33.P9g-9f    00:39:00  01:00:00
34.P4c-4d    00:39:00  01:09:00
35.S4g-5f    00:40:00  01:09:00
36.N8a-7c    00:40:00  01:16:00
37.P4f-4e    00:47:00  01:16:00

Diagram 1

A brave choice by Habu. This position should be the reason to play 
the Kakugawari with tempo loss in the first place. In the normal 
Kakugawari, the white pawn is on 8e instead of 8d, so in this 
reclining silver position white has the extra option of N8e. However, 
this position has appeared in professional games 11 times and black 
won ten times, so statistically it can hardly be called an advantage 
to have the N8e attack. On the other hand, Habu was the only player 
to win from this position with the white pieces. This game seems to 
show that it is not as bad for white as the results seem to indicate.

38.P4dx4e    00:47:00  01:19:00
39.P3f-3e    00:47:00  01:19:00
40.P4e-4f    00:47:00  01:20:00
41.K7i-8h    01:18:00  01:20:00
42.G5b-4c    01:18:00  01:20:00
43.P1f-1e    01:47:00  01:20:00
44.P1dx1e    01:47:00  01:21:00
45.S5f-4e    01:47:00  01:21:00
46.P3dx3e    01:47:00  01:37:00
47.B*5a      01:55:00  01:37:00
48.N7c-8e    01:55:00  01:44:00
49.B5a-7c+   01:55:00  01:44:00
50.R8b-4b    01:55:00  01:44:00
51.+B7cx6d   02:19:00  01:44:00
52.P3e-3f    02:19:00  02:47:00
53.S4ex3f    02:22:00  02:47:00
54.N8ex7g+   02:22:00  02:50:00
55.G7hx7g    02:25:00  02:50:00
56.S*4g      02:25:00  02:51:00
57.S3fx4g    02:32:00  02:51:00
58.P4fx4g+   02:32:00  02:51:00
59.G5hx4g    02:32:00  02:51:00
60.P*3f      02:32:00  02:51:00
61.G4gx3f    02:39:00  02:51:00
62.B*3i      02:39:00  02:51:00
63.R2h-2i    02:56:00  02:51:00
64.B3ix5g+   02:56:00  02:51:00
65.N*3e      03:07:00  02:51:00
66.+B5g-4g   03:07:00  02:57:00
67.R2i-2f    03:08:00  02:57:00
68.+B4g-6i   03:08:00  02:57:00
69.S*7h      03:13:00  02:57:00
70.S*7i      03:13:00  03:01:00
71.K8h-9h    03:14:00  03:01:00
72.+B6i-6h   03:14:00  03:05:00
73.R2f-2h    03:23:00  03:05:00

Diagram 2

74.P9d-9e?   03:23:00  03:14:00

Moriuchi was far from happy with his position here. White has attacked 
first and the difference between the two king positions is considerable. 
On the other hand, the white attack only consists of two pieces, one 
of which (the bishop on 6h) can be taken any time. Furthermore, the 
bishop on 6d works in defense. The position is still very difficult, 
with maybe a slight edge for white. However, 74.P9e, as natural as it 
seems, is an overplay. Better was 74.G3d and after 75.P*4c Sx4c Nx4c+ 
Rx4c P*5d R4i+ Px5c+ K2b white is clearly better.

75.+B6dx9a   03:29:00  03:14:00
76.P9ex9f    03:29:00  03:14:00

With a gold in hand, there is a mate in one. Appealing, but not so easy 
to realize.

77.P8g-8f    03:38:00  03:14:00
78.G4c-3d    03:38:00  03:24:00
79.L*4f!     03:48:00  03:24:00

This lance sacrifice is important, as it defends both against the promotion 
of the rook and against Gx3e Gx3e +Bx3e. This slows down the white attack 
considerably, giving the black king time to try and escape up the board.

80.P*4e      03:48:00  03:35:00
81.K9h-8g    03:48:00  03:35:00

Diagram 3

82.P4ex4f?   03:48:00  03:44:00

Habu was in two minds here: play the natural Px4f, using the lance on the 
9th file to stop the king or play 82.Gx3e 83.Gx3e 84.+Bx4f 85.+Bx4f 86.Px4f. 
In the end, he went for the natural move. A mistake and not really Habu's 
"magic" style. If he would have played 82.Gx3e, then after 86.Px4f black 
can try 87.B*5a, but after R5b Bx3c+ Nx3c P2d Px2d P*3d B*8h white has the 
advantage. Also, 87.P*4c Sx4c N4e S3c-4d seems good for white. There are 
many difficult variations here, so it is impossible to make a definite 
conclusion, but Habu agreed after the game that after 82.Px4f he was in 
trouble and that he should have played 82.Gx3e instead.

83.P*4c      03:48:00  03:44:00
84.R4b-4a?!  03:48:00  03:44:00

Here 84.R5b is better. Black seems to have the advantage then as well, 
but the white position would have been stronger and it would have been 
easier for black to make a mistake.

85.+B9a-6d   03:48:00  03:44:00
86.P4f-4g+   03:48:00  03:44:00
87.P2e-2d!   03:53:00  03:44:00

Diagram 4

The decisive move. 88.Gx2d is answered by 89.N2e and 88.Px2d by 89.P*2c, 
so Habu has no choice.

88.S3cx2d    03:53:00  03:46:00
89.P*3c      03:56:00  03:46:00

The natural attack, but Hashimoto (5-dan) pointed out that 89.Nx2c+ Gx2c 
+Bx5c is also good for black.

90.G3dx3c    03:56:00  03:47:00

Or 90.Nx3c Rx6h Sx6h= B*5b and black wins.

91.N3g-2e    03:57:00  03:47:00
92.G3cx4c    03:57:00  03:48:00
93.N3ex4c+   03:57:00  03:48:00
94.S5dx4c    03:57:00  03:49:00
95.P*3c      03:57:00  03:49:00
96.N2ax3c    03:57:00  03:50:00
97.+B6dx5c   03:58:00  03:50:00
98.K3a-2b    03:58:00  03:50:00
99.N2ex3c+   03:58:00  03:50:00
100.S2dx3c   03:58:00  03:50:00
101.N*4e     03:58:00  03:50:00
102.L*9b     03:58:00  03:56:00
103.N4ex3c+  03:58:00  03:56:00
104.G3bx3c   03:58:00  03:56:00
105.L9ix9f   03:58:00  03:56:00
106.L9bx9f   03:58:00  03:58:00
107.S*4b     03:58:00  03:58:00
108.R4ax4b   03:58:00  03:58:00
109.+B5cx4b  03:58:00  03:58:00
110.P*9e     03:58:00  03:58:00
111.P*9g     03:59:00  03:58:00
112.L9fx9g+  03:59:00  03:59:00
113.N8ix9g   03:59:00  03:59:00
114.S*9f     03:59:00  03:59:00
115.K8g-9h   03:59:00  03:59:00
116.L*9d     03:59:00  03:59:00
117.S7h-8g   03:59:00  03:59:00
Resigns      03:59:00  03:59:00

Final Diagram

After 118.+Bx7g, the bishop no longer defends 1c, so 119.G*2a leads to 
mate. Also, black has Sx9f or Rx6h next, which completely stops the white 
attack. With this win, Moriuchi takes the Kio title from Habu. From 1990, 
Habu won 12 consecutive Kio titles, but the last four years, the title 
has changed hands every year. For Moriuchi, it is the first time he 
takes a title in a one-day title match, the other five titles he won 
have all been in two-day title matches. A great way to celebrate the 
birth of his first child a week earlier.